Best cuisine in Jamaica Plain, Massachusetts
Of course! Grab your fork and pull up a chair, my friend. As your local guide to the vibrant, quirky, and utterly delicious neighborhood of Jamaica Plain, I’m thrilled to take you on a culinary tour. JP isn't just a place on a map; it's a feeling. It's the scent of blooming lilacs in the Arboretum mixing with the aroma of sizzling plantains and wood-fired pizza. It's a community where a century-old Irish pub can sit comfortably next to a modern Dominican joint. We're not just eating here; we're experiencing the soul of Boston, one incredible bite at a time.
Let's dive into the heart of Centre Street and beyond, exploring ten essential spots that define the JP dining scene.
***
### **1. The Joint: Where Reggae Rhythms Meet Smokin' Good Eats**
**605 Centre Street**
Step into **The Joint** and you’re instantly transported. The vibe is laid-back, colorful, and infused with a steady, comforting reggae beat. It’s the kind of place where you can unwind completely, where the service is warm, and the portions are generous. This is unpretentious, soul-satisfying Caribbean comfort food at its absolute finest.
**The Must-Order Experience:**
Do not, I repeat, *do not* leave without trying **The O.G. Jerk Chicken**. This isn't just any jerk chicken; it's a masterpiece. The chicken is marinated for hours in a secret blend of Scotch bonnet peppers, allspice, thyme, and a symphony of other spices, then smoked low and slow until it’s fall-off-the-bone tender. The skin is smoky and slightly crisp, the meat juicy and packing a serious, yet beautifully balanced, fiery punch. It comes with two perfect sides: the **rice and peas** (coconut-infused and fluffy) and the **cabbage** (soft, savory, and the ideal cooling agent for the spice). For a true feast, start with the **Beef Patties** – flaky, golden pastry wrapped around a well-spiced, savory beef filling. They are the handheld definition of happiness.
***
### **2. Pikalo: A Dominican Sunrise in the Heart of JP**
**378 Centre St**
Pikalo is a tiny gem, a no-frills counter service spot that serves up some of the most authentic and beloved Dominican breakfast and lunch in the city. It’s always buzzing with a mix of construction workers, nurses from the nearby hospital, and savvy foodies, all united in the knowledge that they’re about to eat something spectacular.
**The Must-Order Experience:**
You come to Pikalo for one thing: **Los Tres Golpes (The Three Hits)**. This is the legendary Dominican breakfast plate. It features **mangú** (mashed, creamy plantains that are smoother and more savory than any mashed potato you’ve ever had), **fried cheese** (salty and squeaky), **fried salami** (crispy-edged and deeply flavorful), and **fried eggs**. The combination of textures and flavors—creamy, salty, crispy, rich—is nothing short of magical. It’s a hearty, powerful start to your day that will fuel you for hours. Wash it down with a giant glass of their fresh **morir soñando** (to die dreaming), a sublime drink made with orange juice, milk, sugar, and vanilla.
***
### **3. Galway House: The Neighborhood's Time-Honored Anchor**
**710 Centre St**
The Galway House is an institution. This is JP's living room, a sprawling, dimly-lit, wood-paneled Irish-American pub that has been pouring pints and serving hearty plates since 1974. It’s the place for trivia night, for watching the game, for a first date, or for a comforting meal when you need a familiar embrace. It’s not fancy, and it doesn't try to be. It’s just reliably, wonderfully good.
**The Must-Order Experience:**
You have to go classic here. The **Galway Burger** is a thing of beauty—a half-pound of juicy beef, cooked to order, on a soft onion roll with a mountain of crispy, golden **steak fries**. It’s simple, perfect, and exactly what you want. For the true pub experience, order the **Shepherd’s Pie**. It arrives piping hot, with a layer of creamy mashed potatoes blanketing a rich, savory stew of ground beef and vegetables. It’s the definition of comfort in a bowl. And of course, it must be accompanied by a perfectly poured **Guinness**. The thick, creamy head and the dark, complex stout are the only proper companions for this meal.
***
### **4. Tori Japan: Your Go-To for Reliable & Delicious Japanese**
**315 Centre Street #8**
Tucked away in a small plaza, Tori Japan is a humble spot that has earned a fiercely loyal following. It’s primarily a takeout haven, but there are a few stools if you want to eat in. This is where you go for expertly prepared, fresh, and affordable sushi and Japanese kitchen staples. The chefs are focused and efficient, turning out consistently excellent food.
**The Must-Order Experience:**
For sushi lovers, the **Rainbow Roll** is a standout. It’s fresh, beautifully presented, and packed with a variety of fish like tuna, salmon, and yellowtail. But the real sleeper hit is from the kitchen menu: the **Chicken Katsu Don**. A tender, panko-breaded, and deeply crispy chicken cutlet is laid over a bed of rice and smothered in a slightly sweet, savory onion and egg sauce. It’s a warm, comforting, and incredibly satisfying bowl of food that represents the best of Japanese home cooking. Don’t sleep on their gyoza (pan-fried dumplings) either—they’re perfectly crispy on one side and deliciously juicy within.
***
### **5. El Oriental De Cuba: The Crown Jewel of Centre Street**
**416 Centre St**
If JP had a culinary mascot, it might just be El Oriental De Cuba. This place is legendary, a bustling, no-frills cafeteria-style restaurant that has been serving the community for decades. The line often snakes out the door, but it moves fast, and it is 100% worth the wait. The air is thick with the incredible aroma of garlic, citrus, and frying plantains. This is as authentic as it gets outside of Miami or Havana.
**The Must-Order Experience:**
You are legally obligated (in my foodie court) to order the **Cuban Sandwich**. It is, without hyperbole, one of the best you will ever eat. Pressed to perfection on crispy Cuban bread, it layers roast pork, ham, Swiss cheese, pickles, and mustard into a symphony of salty, savory, tangy, and crunchy. But don’t stop there. You must also get a side of **maduros** (sweet, caramelized fried plantains) and **yuca con mojo** (soft, starchy yuca drenched in a pungent, citrusy garlic sauce). For a main, the **Ropa Vieja** (shredded beef in a rich tomato sauce) is a national treasure. Order a Cuban coffee to fuel up—it’s strong, sweet, and served in a tiny cup that packs a mighty punch.
***
### **6. Forest Hills Diner: A Classic American Time Machine**
**3696 Washington St**
This is your classic, no-nonsense, stainless steel-sided diner. Stepping into the Forest Hills Diner is like stepping back in time. It’s cozy, it’s friendly, and it specializes in all the glorious, greasy-spoon classics done right. The coffee is always hot, the booths are cozy, and the servers call you hon. It’s an essential piece of JP’s fabric.
**The Must-Order Experience:**
You come to a diner for breakfast. Period. And you order the **Corned Beef Hash and Eggs**. Their hash is clearly homemade—chunky, savory, and packed with flavor, not the mushy stuff from a can. It’s griddled until crispy on the edges and served with two perfectly cooked eggs (over easy, so the yolk becomes a sauce) and a side of home fries. It’s the ultimate hangover cure and the ultimate comfort meal. For lunch, the patty melt on rye, with Swiss cheese and grilled onions, is a thing of beauty.
***
### **7. Tonino: A Slice of Southern Italy**
**669 Centre St**
Tonino brings a touch of modern, rustic Italian elegance to Centre Street. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with exposed brick and soft lighting, perfect for a date night or a nice dinner with family. The menu is focused on house-made pasta and classic Italian dishes executed with care and high-quality ingredients.
**The Must-Order Experience:**
The pasta is the star here. You cannot go wrong with the **Pappardelle al Ragu di Cinghiale** (wide ribbon pasta with a rich, slow-cooked wild boar ragu). It’s deep, complex, and utterly delicious. If you’re feeling indulgent, the **Lobster Ravioli** in a pink vodka sauce is decadent and luxurious. Before your pasta, share the **Antipasto della Casa**, a beautiful board of Italian meats, cheeses, and marinated vegetables. It’s the perfect start to a truly wonderful Italian meal.
***
### **8. Oriental House: Your Neighborhood Chinese Staple**
**3704 Washington St**
Sometimes, you just need great Chinese takeout. Oriental House has been that reliable, friendly spot for JP residents for years. The menu is extensive, covering all the American-Chinese classics, but they also have a roster of authentic Szechuan and Mandarin dishes for those in the know.
**The Must-Order Experience:**
For a classic, order the **General Gau’s Chicken**. It’s everything you want it to be: chunks of white meat chicken, fried until incredibly crispy, and tossed in a tangy, sweet, and slightly spicy sauce. It’s a crowd-pleaser. For the more adventurous, dive into the Szechuan section and get the **Dan Dan Noodles**. They’re spicy, numbing (from Szechuan peppercorns), nutty, and packed with ground pork and complex flavor. It’s a dish that wakes up every single taste bud.
***
### **9. Blue Frog Bakery: A French-Algonquin Dream**
**3 Green St**
Tucked away on a side street, Blue Frog Bakery is a little piece of Paris meets New England. This small, charming bakery and cafe is known for its exceptional breads, pastries, and simple, elegant lunch offerings. Everything is baked fresh daily, and the quality is palpable.
**The Must-Order Experience:**
Go for breakfast or an early lunch. You must get a **croissant**—it’s flaky, buttery, and shatters perfectly with every bite. For a savory option, their **quiche** is sublime; the crust is impeccable and the filling (whether Lorraine or seasonal vegetable) is always light and flavorful. For lunch, the simple **Jambon-Beurre** (ham and butter on a baguette) is a testament to how magnificent a few perfect ingredients can be. Grab a coffee and a pastry to go, or sit at one of their small tables and watch the neighborhood wake up.
***
### **10. Brendan Behan Pub: A Literary Haven for Pint Philosophers**
**378A Centre St**
Named after the famed Irish playwright, the Brendan Behan Pub is the antithesis of a sports bar. This is a no shit-shooting zone (as their sign famously says), meaning no TVs, no loud music, just the art of conversation. It’s dark, cozy, and filled with books and intellectual chatter. It’s a pub in the traditional sense—a public house for the community to gather and talk.
**The Must-Order Experience:**
The food is simple pub grub, but it’s done well. The focus here is on the drink and the atmosphere. Order a **perfectly poured Harp or Smithwick's** and a **toasted, seasoned popcorn** (it’s complimentary and addictive). If you’re hungry, a **toasted cheese sandwich** or their ** hearty chili** is the ideal, no-fuss accompaniment to your pint and your book. You don’t come to the Behan for a gourmet meal; you come for the ambiance, the conversation, and the feeling of being in a truly unique and special local institution.
***
So there you have it, a culinary map to one of Boston's most delicious neighborhoods. From smoky jerk chicken to perfect Cuban sandwiches, from hearty Irish stews to flaky French pastries, Jamaica Plain feeds your stomach and your soul. Now get out there and explore! Every corner tells a story, and every bite is a chapter. Enjoy
Let's dive into the heart of Centre Street and beyond, exploring ten essential spots that define the JP dining scene.
***
### **1. The Joint: Where Reggae Rhythms Meet Smokin' Good Eats**
**605 Centre Street**
Step into **The Joint** and you’re instantly transported. The vibe is laid-back, colorful, and infused with a steady, comforting reggae beat. It’s the kind of place where you can unwind completely, where the service is warm, and the portions are generous. This is unpretentious, soul-satisfying Caribbean comfort food at its absolute finest.
**The Must-Order Experience:**
Do not, I repeat, *do not* leave without trying **The O.G. Jerk Chicken**. This isn't just any jerk chicken; it's a masterpiece. The chicken is marinated for hours in a secret blend of Scotch bonnet peppers, allspice, thyme, and a symphony of other spices, then smoked low and slow until it’s fall-off-the-bone tender. The skin is smoky and slightly crisp, the meat juicy and packing a serious, yet beautifully balanced, fiery punch. It comes with two perfect sides: the **rice and peas** (coconut-infused and fluffy) and the **cabbage** (soft, savory, and the ideal cooling agent for the spice). For a true feast, start with the **Beef Patties** – flaky, golden pastry wrapped around a well-spiced, savory beef filling. They are the handheld definition of happiness.
***
### **2. Pikalo: A Dominican Sunrise in the Heart of JP**
**378 Centre St**
Pikalo is a tiny gem, a no-frills counter service spot that serves up some of the most authentic and beloved Dominican breakfast and lunch in the city. It’s always buzzing with a mix of construction workers, nurses from the nearby hospital, and savvy foodies, all united in the knowledge that they’re about to eat something spectacular.
**The Must-Order Experience:**
You come to Pikalo for one thing: **Los Tres Golpes (The Three Hits)**. This is the legendary Dominican breakfast plate. It features **mangú** (mashed, creamy plantains that are smoother and more savory than any mashed potato you’ve ever had), **fried cheese** (salty and squeaky), **fried salami** (crispy-edged and deeply flavorful), and **fried eggs**. The combination of textures and flavors—creamy, salty, crispy, rich—is nothing short of magical. It’s a hearty, powerful start to your day that will fuel you for hours. Wash it down with a giant glass of their fresh **morir soñando** (to die dreaming), a sublime drink made with orange juice, milk, sugar, and vanilla.
***
### **3. Galway House: The Neighborhood's Time-Honored Anchor**
**710 Centre St**
The Galway House is an institution. This is JP's living room, a sprawling, dimly-lit, wood-paneled Irish-American pub that has been pouring pints and serving hearty plates since 1974. It’s the place for trivia night, for watching the game, for a first date, or for a comforting meal when you need a familiar embrace. It’s not fancy, and it doesn't try to be. It’s just reliably, wonderfully good.
**The Must-Order Experience:**
You have to go classic here. The **Galway Burger** is a thing of beauty—a half-pound of juicy beef, cooked to order, on a soft onion roll with a mountain of crispy, golden **steak fries**. It’s simple, perfect, and exactly what you want. For the true pub experience, order the **Shepherd’s Pie**. It arrives piping hot, with a layer of creamy mashed potatoes blanketing a rich, savory stew of ground beef and vegetables. It’s the definition of comfort in a bowl. And of course, it must be accompanied by a perfectly poured **Guinness**. The thick, creamy head and the dark, complex stout are the only proper companions for this meal.
***
### **4. Tori Japan: Your Go-To for Reliable & Delicious Japanese**
**315 Centre Street #8**
Tucked away in a small plaza, Tori Japan is a humble spot that has earned a fiercely loyal following. It’s primarily a takeout haven, but there are a few stools if you want to eat in. This is where you go for expertly prepared, fresh, and affordable sushi and Japanese kitchen staples. The chefs are focused and efficient, turning out consistently excellent food.
**The Must-Order Experience:**
For sushi lovers, the **Rainbow Roll** is a standout. It’s fresh, beautifully presented, and packed with a variety of fish like tuna, salmon, and yellowtail. But the real sleeper hit is from the kitchen menu: the **Chicken Katsu Don**. A tender, panko-breaded, and deeply crispy chicken cutlet is laid over a bed of rice and smothered in a slightly sweet, savory onion and egg sauce. It’s a warm, comforting, and incredibly satisfying bowl of food that represents the best of Japanese home cooking. Don’t sleep on their gyoza (pan-fried dumplings) either—they’re perfectly crispy on one side and deliciously juicy within.
***
### **5. El Oriental De Cuba: The Crown Jewel of Centre Street**
**416 Centre St**
If JP had a culinary mascot, it might just be El Oriental De Cuba. This place is legendary, a bustling, no-frills cafeteria-style restaurant that has been serving the community for decades. The line often snakes out the door, but it moves fast, and it is 100% worth the wait. The air is thick with the incredible aroma of garlic, citrus, and frying plantains. This is as authentic as it gets outside of Miami or Havana.
**The Must-Order Experience:**
You are legally obligated (in my foodie court) to order the **Cuban Sandwich**. It is, without hyperbole, one of the best you will ever eat. Pressed to perfection on crispy Cuban bread, it layers roast pork, ham, Swiss cheese, pickles, and mustard into a symphony of salty, savory, tangy, and crunchy. But don’t stop there. You must also get a side of **maduros** (sweet, caramelized fried plantains) and **yuca con mojo** (soft, starchy yuca drenched in a pungent, citrusy garlic sauce). For a main, the **Ropa Vieja** (shredded beef in a rich tomato sauce) is a national treasure. Order a Cuban coffee to fuel up—it’s strong, sweet, and served in a tiny cup that packs a mighty punch.
***
### **6. Forest Hills Diner: A Classic American Time Machine**
**3696 Washington St**
This is your classic, no-nonsense, stainless steel-sided diner. Stepping into the Forest Hills Diner is like stepping back in time. It’s cozy, it’s friendly, and it specializes in all the glorious, greasy-spoon classics done right. The coffee is always hot, the booths are cozy, and the servers call you hon. It’s an essential piece of JP’s fabric.
**The Must-Order Experience:**
You come to a diner for breakfast. Period. And you order the **Corned Beef Hash and Eggs**. Their hash is clearly homemade—chunky, savory, and packed with flavor, not the mushy stuff from a can. It’s griddled until crispy on the edges and served with two perfectly cooked eggs (over easy, so the yolk becomes a sauce) and a side of home fries. It’s the ultimate hangover cure and the ultimate comfort meal. For lunch, the patty melt on rye, with Swiss cheese and grilled onions, is a thing of beauty.
***
### **7. Tonino: A Slice of Southern Italy**
**669 Centre St**
Tonino brings a touch of modern, rustic Italian elegance to Centre Street. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with exposed brick and soft lighting, perfect for a date night or a nice dinner with family. The menu is focused on house-made pasta and classic Italian dishes executed with care and high-quality ingredients.
**The Must-Order Experience:**
The pasta is the star here. You cannot go wrong with the **Pappardelle al Ragu di Cinghiale** (wide ribbon pasta with a rich, slow-cooked wild boar ragu). It’s deep, complex, and utterly delicious. If you’re feeling indulgent, the **Lobster Ravioli** in a pink vodka sauce is decadent and luxurious. Before your pasta, share the **Antipasto della Casa**, a beautiful board of Italian meats, cheeses, and marinated vegetables. It’s the perfect start to a truly wonderful Italian meal.
***
### **8. Oriental House: Your Neighborhood Chinese Staple**
**3704 Washington St**
Sometimes, you just need great Chinese takeout. Oriental House has been that reliable, friendly spot for JP residents for years. The menu is extensive, covering all the American-Chinese classics, but they also have a roster of authentic Szechuan and Mandarin dishes for those in the know.
**The Must-Order Experience:**
For a classic, order the **General Gau’s Chicken**. It’s everything you want it to be: chunks of white meat chicken, fried until incredibly crispy, and tossed in a tangy, sweet, and slightly spicy sauce. It’s a crowd-pleaser. For the more adventurous, dive into the Szechuan section and get the **Dan Dan Noodles**. They’re spicy, numbing (from Szechuan peppercorns), nutty, and packed with ground pork and complex flavor. It’s a dish that wakes up every single taste bud.
***
### **9. Blue Frog Bakery: A French-Algonquin Dream**
**3 Green St**
Tucked away on a side street, Blue Frog Bakery is a little piece of Paris meets New England. This small, charming bakery and cafe is known for its exceptional breads, pastries, and simple, elegant lunch offerings. Everything is baked fresh daily, and the quality is palpable.
**The Must-Order Experience:**
Go for breakfast or an early lunch. You must get a **croissant**—it’s flaky, buttery, and shatters perfectly with every bite. For a savory option, their **quiche** is sublime; the crust is impeccable and the filling (whether Lorraine or seasonal vegetable) is always light and flavorful. For lunch, the simple **Jambon-Beurre** (ham and butter on a baguette) is a testament to how magnificent a few perfect ingredients can be. Grab a coffee and a pastry to go, or sit at one of their small tables and watch the neighborhood wake up.
***
### **10. Brendan Behan Pub: A Literary Haven for Pint Philosophers**
**378A Centre St**
Named after the famed Irish playwright, the Brendan Behan Pub is the antithesis of a sports bar. This is a no shit-shooting zone (as their sign famously says), meaning no TVs, no loud music, just the art of conversation. It’s dark, cozy, and filled with books and intellectual chatter. It’s a pub in the traditional sense—a public house for the community to gather and talk.
**The Must-Order Experience:**
The food is simple pub grub, but it’s done well. The focus here is on the drink and the atmosphere. Order a **perfectly poured Harp or Smithwick's** and a **toasted, seasoned popcorn** (it’s complimentary and addictive). If you’re hungry, a **toasted cheese sandwich** or their ** hearty chili** is the ideal, no-fuss accompaniment to your pint and your book. You don’t come to the Behan for a gourmet meal; you come for the ambiance, the conversation, and the feeling of being in a truly unique and special local institution.
***
So there you have it, a culinary map to one of Boston's most delicious neighborhoods. From smoky jerk chicken to perfect Cuban sandwiches, from hearty Irish stews to flaky French pastries, Jamaica Plain feeds your stomach and your soul. Now get out there and explore! Every corner tells a story, and every bite is a chapter. Enjoy
Comments
Post a Comment