All-hits-no-misses for foodies in Nantucket, Massachusetts
# A Culinary Journey through Nantucket: Discovering Unforgettable Dining Experiences
Nestled in the Atlantic Ocean, Nantucket is known for its stunning landscapes, charming cobblestone streets, and rich maritime history. However, one of the hidden gems of this island paradise is its vibrant culinary scene. If you're a foodie looking to experience innovative dishes, locally sourced ingredients, and a plethora of delectable options, here’s a detailed guide to ten must-visit eateries in Nantucket. From casual sandwich shops to upscale dining, each spot offers a unique taste of the island.
---
### 1. Henry’s Jr. Sandwich Shop
**Address:** 129 Orange St, Nantucket, Massachusetts, 02554
**[Restaurant URL](https://zmenu.com/henry-s-jr-sandwich-shop-nantucket)**
**[Sample Menu URL](
)**
Henry’s Jr. Sandwich Shop is a beloved local hangout where you can savor hearty, gourmet sandwiches made with fresh, quality ingredients. With an eclectic range of sandwiches and a warm, friendly atmosphere, this shop has become a staple for both locals and tourists alike.
#### What to Order:
- **The Classic Lobster Roll**: A must-try, this roll is filled with succulent pieces of fresh lobster mixed with a light mayo on a toasted bun, bursting with the flavors of the sea.
- **The Reuben**: Perfectly toasted rye bread with tender corned beef, sauerkraut, and creamy thousand island dressing delivers a rich, savory bite that’s hard to resist.
- **Veggie Delight**: For the plant-based options, the Veggie Delight packed with fresh greens, avocado, and sun-dried tomatoes is a refreshing break from the heavier fare.
---
### 2. Surfside Beach Shack
**Address:** 160 Surfside Rd, Nantucket, Massachusetts, 02554
**[Restaurant URL](https://zmenu.com/surfside-beach-shack-nantucket)**
**[Sample Menu URL](
)**
With a prime location near the beach, Surfside Beach Shack lets you indulge in tasty bites while soaking in the sun. Known for its vibrant atmosphere and laid-back vibe, this beach shack is perfect for a delightful day of fun and food.
#### What to Order:
- **Fish Tacos**: The lightly battered fish served in corn tortillas topped with pico de gallo and chipotle mayo is the epitome of beach food done right.
- **Classic Cheeseburger**: Juicy and flavorful, this simple burger melted cheese is ideal for those after something classic and comforting.
- **Shack Fries**: Don’t forget to pair your meal with a generous serving of Shack Fries, seasoned to perfection and worthy of sharing.
---
### 3. The Muse
**Address:** 44 Surfside Rd, Nantucket, Massachusetts, 02554
**[Restaurant URL](https://zmenu.com/muse-pizza-nantucket)**
**[Sample Menu URL](
)**
The Muse is a cozy spot that serves artisanal pizza and has gained popularity for its wood-fired oven and a wide variety of toppings. This rustic yet chic eatery is perfect for family gatherings or casual dates.
#### What to Order:
- **Margherita Pizza**: A classic made with fresh basil, mozzarella, and a tangy tomato sauce, providing a refreshing taste of simplicity and local ingredients.
- **Beet and Goat Cheese Salad**: A delightful starter featuring roasted beets and creamy goat cheese, it's a perfect lighter choice before the main course.
- **Dessert Pizza**: For a sweet ending, try their dessert pizza topped with Nutella and fresh fruits, offering a divine combination of flavors.
---
### 4. Yezzi's Nantucket
**Address:** 67 Old South Rd, Nantucket, Massachusetts, 02554
**[Restaurant URL](https://zmenu.com/yezzis-nantucket-nantucket)**
**[Sample Menu URL](
)**
Yezzi's Nantucket serves up American comfort food with a twist, featuring hearty portions and an inviting atmosphere. This is the place to enjoy a cozy meal with friends and family.
#### What to Order:
- **Fried Chicken Sandwich**: Crisp and juicy, served with pickles and spicy mayo — the perfect bite that you can have any time of the day.
- **Maine Lobster Grilled Cheese**: Elevate your grilled cheese experience with fresh lobster packed between two slices of buttery, toasted bread.
- **Milkshakes**: Don’t leave without trying one of their decadent milkshakes — creamy and customizable with a range of toppings.
---
### 5. Walters Deli
**Address:** 10 Broad St, Nantucket, Massachusetts, 02554
**[Restaurant URL](https://zmenu.com/walters-deli-nantucket)**
**[Sample Menu URL](
)**
This charming deli is perfect for grabbing a quick bite or a picnic meal before heading out for a day of exploration. Walters Deli is known for its extensive menu of sandwiches, salads, and daily specials.
#### What to Order:
- **The Italian Sub**: Packaged with layers of cured meats, provolone, and fresh veggies, this sandwich is a flavorsome treat that is consistently praised by locals.
- **Pasta Salads**: Opt for one of their fresh pasta salads, perfect as a side or a light lunch, usually loaded with seasonal veggies.
- **Bakery Items**: Pair your meal with one of their freshly baked pastries or cookies for a sweet bite to end your deli experience.
---
### 6. Born & Bread Nantucket
**Address:** 35 Centre St, Nantucket, Massachusetts, 02554
**[Restaurant URL](https://zmenu.com/born-and-bread-nantucket-nantucket)**
**[Sample Menu URL](
)**
A haven for breakfast lovers, Born & Bread is famous for its artisan breads and pastries. The rustic decor, complemented by an array of baked goods, creates a perfect ambiance for a brunch date or a lazy morning meal.
#### What to Order:
- **Avocado Toast**: Topped with poached eggs, this modern classic is both nutritious and Instagram-worthy.
- **Cinnamon Buns**: Savory and indulgent, their freshly baked cinnamon buns are not to be missed, drizzled with icing that melts in your mouth.
- **Seasonal Quiche**: Offering a rotating menu of quiche, always made with local ingredients — it's a delightful choice for an egg lover.
---
### 7. Faregrounds Restaurant
**Address:** 27 Fairgrounds Rd, Nantucket, Massachusetts, 02554
**[Restaurant URL](https://zmenu.com/faregrounds-and-pudleys-pub-nantucket)**
**[Sample Menu URL](
)**
Faregrounds is known for its casual ambiance and a robust menu featuring American classics. Whether you're seeking a hearty breakfast or a perfectly grilled dinner, Faregrounds provides a welcoming atmosphere.
#### What to Order:
- **Fish and Chips**: Crispy and flavorful, this dish is served with hand-cut fries and house-made tartar sauce for the ultimate comfort food experience.
- **Brewery Burger**: Their signature burger is stacked high with toppings of your choice, grilled to perfection.
- **Homemade Desserts**: Don’t skip dessert here; their rotating selection of pies and cakes is made in-house and sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.
---
### 8. The Seagrille
**Address:** 45 Sparks Ave, Nantucket, Massachusetts, 02554
**[Restaurant URL](https://zmenu.com/sea-grille-nantucket)**
**[Sample Menu URL](
)**
For a more upscale dining experience, The Seagrille offers an elegant atmosphere paired with seasonal dishes that spotlight the freshest local seafood and meats. With stunning interior decor and a lovely outdoor patio, it’s the perfect spot for a romantic evening.
#### What to Order:
- **Pan-Seared Scallops**: Freshly caught scallops served with seasonal veggies and a citrus sauce, providing an exquisite flavor fit for a special occasion.
- **Nantucket Bay Scallop Risotto**: Creamy and flavorful, this dish showcases the best of local seafood in a rich, satisfying meal.
- **Lobster Bisque**: Smooth and sumptuous, their lobster bisque is crafted with a perfect blend of spices and a hint of cream, offering a taste of coastal luxury.
---
### 9. GypSea Café
**Address:** Children's Beach, 7 Harbor View Way, Nantucket, Massachusetts, 02554
**[Restaurant URL](https://zmenu.com/gypsea-café-nantucket-2)**
**[Sample Menu URL](
)**
Set against the picturesque background of Children's Beach, GypSea Café boasts an inviting atmosphere perfect for families or casual gatherings. The café serves an array of wholesome dishes and is especially known for its breakfast and smoothie bowls.
#### What to Order:
- **Acai Bowls**: Refreshing, vibrant, and topped with fresh fruits, nuts, and honey, these bowls provide the ultimate healthy start to your day.
- **Breakfast Burrito**: Packed with eggs, cheese, and your choice of proteins, this hearty burrito is ideal for breakfast lovers needing a quick bite.
- **Fresh Juices**: Quench your thirst with their freshly pressed juices, offering various health-boosting mixtures seasonally designed.
---
### 10. Stubbys
**Address:** 8 Steamboat Wharf, Nantucket, Massachusetts, 02554
**[Restaurant URL](https://zmenu.com/stubbys-nantucket)**
**[Sample Menu URL](
)**
Stubbys is a casual, lively eatery operated with a commitment to providing delicious food coupled with lively vibes. Overlooking the harbor, it’s an ideal spot for enjoying a drink and bites after a long day of exploring.
#### What to Order:
- **Seafood Platter**: Rich with the taste of the ocean, this platter is filled with clams, shrimp, and calamari; it's an excellent choice for seafood aficionados.
- **Signature Nachos**: Crispy tortilla chips crowned with cheese, jalapeños, and your choice of protein makes for a perfect sharing dish.
- **Craft Beers**: Local craft beers on tap offer a great selection for connoisseurs looking to pair their meals with something refreshing.
---
### Conclusion
Nantucket seamlessly blends a charming coastal town ambiance with a culinary scene that is equally rich and diverse. From sandwiches and beachside fare to gourmet dining experiences, the island's eateries are sure to satisfy every palate. Whether you're visiting for a weekend getaway or a long summer vacation, make sure to explore the unique flavors and carefully crafted dishes this picturesque island has to offer. Happy dining!
Nestled in the Atlantic Ocean, Nantucket is known for its stunning landscapes, charming cobblestone streets, and rich maritime history. However, one of the hidden gems of this island paradise is its vibrant culinary scene. If you're a foodie looking to experience innovative dishes, locally sourced ingredients, and a plethora of delectable options, here’s a detailed guide to ten must-visit eateries in Nantucket. From casual sandwich shops to upscale dining, each spot offers a unique taste of the island.
---
### 1. Henry’s Jr. Sandwich Shop
**Address:** 129 Orange St, Nantucket, Massachusetts, 02554
**[Restaurant URL](https://zmenu.com/henry-s-jr-sandwich-shop-nantucket)**
**[Sample Menu URL](
)**
Henry’s Jr. Sandwich Shop is a beloved local hangout where you can savor hearty, gourmet sandwiches made with fresh, quality ingredients. With an eclectic range of sandwiches and a warm, friendly atmosphere, this shop has become a staple for both locals and tourists alike.
#### What to Order:
- **The Classic Lobster Roll**: A must-try, this roll is filled with succulent pieces of fresh lobster mixed with a light mayo on a toasted bun, bursting with the flavors of the sea.
- **The Reuben**: Perfectly toasted rye bread with tender corned beef, sauerkraut, and creamy thousand island dressing delivers a rich, savory bite that’s hard to resist.
- **Veggie Delight**: For the plant-based options, the Veggie Delight packed with fresh greens, avocado, and sun-dried tomatoes is a refreshing break from the heavier fare.
---
### 2. Surfside Beach Shack
**Address:** 160 Surfside Rd, Nantucket, Massachusetts, 02554
**[Restaurant URL](https://zmenu.com/surfside-beach-shack-nantucket)**
**[Sample Menu URL](
)**
With a prime location near the beach, Surfside Beach Shack lets you indulge in tasty bites while soaking in the sun. Known for its vibrant atmosphere and laid-back vibe, this beach shack is perfect for a delightful day of fun and food.
#### What to Order:
- **Fish Tacos**: The lightly battered fish served in corn tortillas topped with pico de gallo and chipotle mayo is the epitome of beach food done right.
- **Classic Cheeseburger**: Juicy and flavorful, this simple burger melted cheese is ideal for those after something classic and comforting.
- **Shack Fries**: Don’t forget to pair your meal with a generous serving of Shack Fries, seasoned to perfection and worthy of sharing.
---
### 3. The Muse
**Address:** 44 Surfside Rd, Nantucket, Massachusetts, 02554
**[Restaurant URL](https://zmenu.com/muse-pizza-nantucket)**
**[Sample Menu URL](
)**
The Muse is a cozy spot that serves artisanal pizza and has gained popularity for its wood-fired oven and a wide variety of toppings. This rustic yet chic eatery is perfect for family gatherings or casual dates.
#### What to Order:
- **Margherita Pizza**: A classic made with fresh basil, mozzarella, and a tangy tomato sauce, providing a refreshing taste of simplicity and local ingredients.
- **Beet and Goat Cheese Salad**: A delightful starter featuring roasted beets and creamy goat cheese, it's a perfect lighter choice before the main course.
- **Dessert Pizza**: For a sweet ending, try their dessert pizza topped with Nutella and fresh fruits, offering a divine combination of flavors.
---
### 4. Yezzi's Nantucket
**Address:** 67 Old South Rd, Nantucket, Massachusetts, 02554
**[Restaurant URL](https://zmenu.com/yezzis-nantucket-nantucket)**
**[Sample Menu URL](
)**
Yezzi's Nantucket serves up American comfort food with a twist, featuring hearty portions and an inviting atmosphere. This is the place to enjoy a cozy meal with friends and family.
#### What to Order:
- **Fried Chicken Sandwich**: Crisp and juicy, served with pickles and spicy mayo — the perfect bite that you can have any time of the day.
- **Maine Lobster Grilled Cheese**: Elevate your grilled cheese experience with fresh lobster packed between two slices of buttery, toasted bread.
- **Milkshakes**: Don’t leave without trying one of their decadent milkshakes — creamy and customizable with a range of toppings.
---
### 5. Walters Deli
**Address:** 10 Broad St, Nantucket, Massachusetts, 02554
**[Restaurant URL](https://zmenu.com/walters-deli-nantucket)**
**[Sample Menu URL](
)**
This charming deli is perfect for grabbing a quick bite or a picnic meal before heading out for a day of exploration. Walters Deli is known for its extensive menu of sandwiches, salads, and daily specials.
#### What to Order:
- **The Italian Sub**: Packaged with layers of cured meats, provolone, and fresh veggies, this sandwich is a flavorsome treat that is consistently praised by locals.
- **Pasta Salads**: Opt for one of their fresh pasta salads, perfect as a side or a light lunch, usually loaded with seasonal veggies.
- **Bakery Items**: Pair your meal with one of their freshly baked pastries or cookies for a sweet bite to end your deli experience.
---
### 6. Born & Bread Nantucket
**Address:** 35 Centre St, Nantucket, Massachusetts, 02554
**[Restaurant URL](https://zmenu.com/born-and-bread-nantucket-nantucket)**
**[Sample Menu URL](
)**
A haven for breakfast lovers, Born & Bread is famous for its artisan breads and pastries. The rustic decor, complemented by an array of baked goods, creates a perfect ambiance for a brunch date or a lazy morning meal.
#### What to Order:
- **Avocado Toast**: Topped with poached eggs, this modern classic is both nutritious and Instagram-worthy.
- **Cinnamon Buns**: Savory and indulgent, their freshly baked cinnamon buns are not to be missed, drizzled with icing that melts in your mouth.
- **Seasonal Quiche**: Offering a rotating menu of quiche, always made with local ingredients — it's a delightful choice for an egg lover.
---
### 7. Faregrounds Restaurant
**Address:** 27 Fairgrounds Rd, Nantucket, Massachusetts, 02554
**[Restaurant URL](https://zmenu.com/faregrounds-and-pudleys-pub-nantucket)**
**[Sample Menu URL](
)**
Faregrounds is known for its casual ambiance and a robust menu featuring American classics. Whether you're seeking a hearty breakfast or a perfectly grilled dinner, Faregrounds provides a welcoming atmosphere.
#### What to Order:
- **Fish and Chips**: Crispy and flavorful, this dish is served with hand-cut fries and house-made tartar sauce for the ultimate comfort food experience.
- **Brewery Burger**: Their signature burger is stacked high with toppings of your choice, grilled to perfection.
- **Homemade Desserts**: Don’t skip dessert here; their rotating selection of pies and cakes is made in-house and sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.
---
### 8. The Seagrille
**Address:** 45 Sparks Ave, Nantucket, Massachusetts, 02554
**[Restaurant URL](https://zmenu.com/sea-grille-nantucket)**
**[Sample Menu URL](
)**
For a more upscale dining experience, The Seagrille offers an elegant atmosphere paired with seasonal dishes that spotlight the freshest local seafood and meats. With stunning interior decor and a lovely outdoor patio, it’s the perfect spot for a romantic evening.
#### What to Order:
- **Pan-Seared Scallops**: Freshly caught scallops served with seasonal veggies and a citrus sauce, providing an exquisite flavor fit for a special occasion.
- **Nantucket Bay Scallop Risotto**: Creamy and flavorful, this dish showcases the best of local seafood in a rich, satisfying meal.
- **Lobster Bisque**: Smooth and sumptuous, their lobster bisque is crafted with a perfect blend of spices and a hint of cream, offering a taste of coastal luxury.
---
### 9. GypSea Café
**Address:** Children's Beach, 7 Harbor View Way, Nantucket, Massachusetts, 02554
**[Restaurant URL](https://zmenu.com/gypsea-café-nantucket-2)**
**[Sample Menu URL](
)**
Set against the picturesque background of Children's Beach, GypSea Café boasts an inviting atmosphere perfect for families or casual gatherings. The café serves an array of wholesome dishes and is especially known for its breakfast and smoothie bowls.
#### What to Order:
- **Acai Bowls**: Refreshing, vibrant, and topped with fresh fruits, nuts, and honey, these bowls provide the ultimate healthy start to your day.
- **Breakfast Burrito**: Packed with eggs, cheese, and your choice of proteins, this hearty burrito is ideal for breakfast lovers needing a quick bite.
- **Fresh Juices**: Quench your thirst with their freshly pressed juices, offering various health-boosting mixtures seasonally designed.
---
### 10. Stubbys
**Address:** 8 Steamboat Wharf, Nantucket, Massachusetts, 02554
**[Restaurant URL](https://zmenu.com/stubbys-nantucket)**
**[Sample Menu URL](
)**
Stubbys is a casual, lively eatery operated with a commitment to providing delicious food coupled with lively vibes. Overlooking the harbor, it’s an ideal spot for enjoying a drink and bites after a long day of exploring.
#### What to Order:
- **Seafood Platter**: Rich with the taste of the ocean, this platter is filled with clams, shrimp, and calamari; it's an excellent choice for seafood aficionados.
- **Signature Nachos**: Crispy tortilla chips crowned with cheese, jalapeños, and your choice of protein makes for a perfect sharing dish.
- **Craft Beers**: Local craft beers on tap offer a great selection for connoisseurs looking to pair their meals with something refreshing.
---
### Conclusion
Nantucket seamlessly blends a charming coastal town ambiance with a culinary scene that is equally rich and diverse. From sandwiches and beachside fare to gourmet dining experiences, the island's eateries are sure to satisfy every palate. Whether you're visiting for a weekend getaway or a long summer vacation, make sure to explore the unique flavors and carefully crafted dishes this picturesque island has to offer. Happy dining!
Comments
Post a Comment