Foodie's top picks in West Bend, Wisconsin
# **A Foodie’s Guide to West Bend, Wisconsin: Where to Dine and What to Order**
Nestled in the heart of Washington County, West Bend, Wisconsin, is a hidden gem for food lovers. From classic supper clubs and smoky BBQ joints to authentic Mexican fare and irresistible frozen custard, this charming town offers a diverse culinary scene that deserves a spotlight. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this guide will take you through the best dining experiences West Bend has to offer—complete with must-try dishes at each stop.
---
## **1. Wallace Lake Supper Club**
? *2472 Wallace Lake Rd, West Bend, WI 53090*
? [Menu](
)
### **The Experience:**
A true Wisconsin tradition, Wallace Lake Supper Club embodies the nostalgic charm of classic supper clubs—dim lighting, cozy booths, and a welcoming bar where Old Fashioneds are practically mandatory. Perched near the serene Wallace Lake, this spot is perfect for a relaxed evening of hearty meals and stiff drinks.
### **What to Order:**
- **Prime Rib (Friday & Saturday Special)** – Slow-roasted, tender, and served with au jus, a baked potato, and horseradish.
- **Walleye Pike** – A Wisconsin favorite, lightly breaded and fried to golden perfection.
- **Brandy Old Fashioned (Sweet or Sour)** – No supper club experience is complete without one.
**Pro Tip:** Arrive early for their famous Friday fish fry—locals swear by it!
---
## **2. Jug’s Hitching Post Saloon & Grill**
? *5781 Main St, West Bend, WI 53090*
? [Menu](
)
### **The Experience:**
A rustic tavern with a lively atmosphere, Jug’s Hitching Post is where locals gather for cold beer, juicy burgers, and live music. The walls are lined with vintage memorabilia, and the outdoor patio is a summer hotspot.
### **What to Order:**
- **Hitching Post Burger** – A half-pound behemoth with cheese, bacon, and all the fixings.
- **BBQ Ribs** – Fall-off-the-bone tender, slathered in house-made sauce.
- **Wisconsin Cheese Curds** – Fresh, squeaky, and fried to crispy perfection.
**Pro Tip:** Check their Facebook page for live music nights—great energy and cold brews!
---
## **3. Hankerson’s Country Oven Bakery**
? *2107 W Washington St, West Bend, WI 53095*
? [Menu](
)
### **The Experience:**
A family-owned bakery that feels like stepping into Grandma’s kitchen, Hankerson’s is a must for pastry lovers. The scent of fresh bread, cinnamon rolls, and pies fills the air, making it impossible to leave without a treat (or three).
### **What to Order:**
- **Cinnamon Rolls** – Huge, gooey, and topped with thick icing.
- **Apple Fritters** – Crispy outside, soft inside, packed with cinnamon-spiced apples.
- **Long Johns (Cream-Filled Donuts)** – A Midwest classic, best enjoyed with coffee.
**Pro Tip:** Get there early—their best-selling items sell out fast!
---
## **4. Don Tacos & Tequila**
? *326 Commerce St, West Bend, WI 53090*
? [Menu](
)
### **The Experience:**
A vibrant, modern taqueria with a killer tequila selection, Don Tacos & Tequila brings authentic Mexican flavors to West Bend. The colorful décor and friendly service make it a fun spot for margarita-fueled fiestas.
### **What to Order:**
- **Al Pastor Tacos** – Marinated pork with pineapple, cilantro, and onions.
- **Quesabirria** – Melty, cheesy, and served with rich consommé for dipping.
- **Mango-Habanero Margarita** – Spicy, sweet, and dangerously smooth.
**Pro Tip:** Taco Tuesdays mean $2 tacos—don’t miss out!
---
## **5. Nuckleheadz Bar & Grill**
? *3680 County Hwy NN, West Bend, WI 53095*
? [Menu](
)
### **The Experience:**
A no-frills, friendly neighborhood bar with generous portions and a laid-back vibe. Nuckleheadz is the kind of place where everyone knows your name—and the burgers are legendary.
### **What to Order:**
- **Nuckleheadz Burger** – Loaded with bacon, cheese, and a secret sauce.
- **Breaded Mushrooms** – Crispy, golden, and served with ranch.
- **Friday Fish Fry** – Beer-battered cod with all the classic fixings.
**Pro Tip:** Their bloody marys come loaded with snacks—perfect for weekend brunch.
---
*(Continued in next comment due to length limits...)*
Nestled in the heart of Washington County, West Bend, Wisconsin, is a hidden gem for food lovers. From classic supper clubs and smoky BBQ joints to authentic Mexican fare and irresistible frozen custard, this charming town offers a diverse culinary scene that deserves a spotlight. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this guide will take you through the best dining experiences West Bend has to offer—complete with must-try dishes at each stop.
---
## **1. Wallace Lake Supper Club**
? *2472 Wallace Lake Rd, West Bend, WI 53090*
? [Menu](
)
### **The Experience:**
A true Wisconsin tradition, Wallace Lake Supper Club embodies the nostalgic charm of classic supper clubs—dim lighting, cozy booths, and a welcoming bar where Old Fashioneds are practically mandatory. Perched near the serene Wallace Lake, this spot is perfect for a relaxed evening of hearty meals and stiff drinks.
### **What to Order:**
- **Prime Rib (Friday & Saturday Special)** – Slow-roasted, tender, and served with au jus, a baked potato, and horseradish.
- **Walleye Pike** – A Wisconsin favorite, lightly breaded and fried to golden perfection.
- **Brandy Old Fashioned (Sweet or Sour)** – No supper club experience is complete without one.
**Pro Tip:** Arrive early for their famous Friday fish fry—locals swear by it!
---
## **2. Jug’s Hitching Post Saloon & Grill**
? *5781 Main St, West Bend, WI 53090*
? [Menu](
)
### **The Experience:**
A rustic tavern with a lively atmosphere, Jug’s Hitching Post is where locals gather for cold beer, juicy burgers, and live music. The walls are lined with vintage memorabilia, and the outdoor patio is a summer hotspot.
### **What to Order:**
- **Hitching Post Burger** – A half-pound behemoth with cheese, bacon, and all the fixings.
- **BBQ Ribs** – Fall-off-the-bone tender, slathered in house-made sauce.
- **Wisconsin Cheese Curds** – Fresh, squeaky, and fried to crispy perfection.
**Pro Tip:** Check their Facebook page for live music nights—great energy and cold brews!
---
## **3. Hankerson’s Country Oven Bakery**
? *2107 W Washington St, West Bend, WI 53095*
? [Menu](
)
### **The Experience:**
A family-owned bakery that feels like stepping into Grandma’s kitchen, Hankerson’s is a must for pastry lovers. The scent of fresh bread, cinnamon rolls, and pies fills the air, making it impossible to leave without a treat (or three).
### **What to Order:**
- **Cinnamon Rolls** – Huge, gooey, and topped with thick icing.
- **Apple Fritters** – Crispy outside, soft inside, packed with cinnamon-spiced apples.
- **Long Johns (Cream-Filled Donuts)** – A Midwest classic, best enjoyed with coffee.
**Pro Tip:** Get there early—their best-selling items sell out fast!
---
## **4. Don Tacos & Tequila**
? *326 Commerce St, West Bend, WI 53090*
? [Menu](
)
### **The Experience:**
A vibrant, modern taqueria with a killer tequila selection, Don Tacos & Tequila brings authentic Mexican flavors to West Bend. The colorful décor and friendly service make it a fun spot for margarita-fueled fiestas.
### **What to Order:**
- **Al Pastor Tacos** – Marinated pork with pineapple, cilantro, and onions.
- **Quesabirria** – Melty, cheesy, and served with rich consommé for dipping.
- **Mango-Habanero Margarita** – Spicy, sweet, and dangerously smooth.
**Pro Tip:** Taco Tuesdays mean $2 tacos—don’t miss out!
---
## **5. Nuckleheadz Bar & Grill**
? *3680 County Hwy NN, West Bend, WI 53095*
? [Menu](
)
### **The Experience:**
A no-frills, friendly neighborhood bar with generous portions and a laid-back vibe. Nuckleheadz is the kind of place where everyone knows your name—and the burgers are legendary.
### **What to Order:**
- **Nuckleheadz Burger** – Loaded with bacon, cheese, and a secret sauce.
- **Breaded Mushrooms** – Crispy, golden, and served with ranch.
- **Friday Fish Fry** – Beer-battered cod with all the classic fixings.
**Pro Tip:** Their bloody marys come loaded with snacks—perfect for weekend brunch.
---
*(Continued in next comment due to length limits...)*
Comments
Post a Comment