Delicious tour in Smithtown, New York
# **A Foodie’s Guide to Smithtown, NY: 10 Must-Try Dining Spots**
Nestled in the heart of Long Island, Smithtown, New York, is a hidden gem for food lovers. From authentic Italian trattorias to cozy Irish pubs and bustling delis, this charming town offers a diverse culinary scene that caters to every palate. Whether you're craving fresh seafood, hearty breakfasts, or bold international flavors, Smithtown has something delicious waiting for you.
Join us as we explore ten of the best dining spots in town, highlighting must-try dishes, ambiance, and what makes each place special.
---
## **1. Casa Luis – A Taste of Mexico on Jericho Turnpike**
? **1033 W Jericho Turnpike, Smithtown, NY 11787**
? **[Menu](
)**
**Why Visit?**
Casa Luis brings the vibrant flavors of Mexico to Smithtown with its colorful decor, friendly service, and bold dishes. The restaurant is a local favorite for its generous portions and authentic recipes.
**Must-Order:**
- **Carne Asada Tacos** – Tender grilled steak, fresh cilantro, and onions on warm corn tortillas.
- **Chiles Rellenos** – Poblano peppers stuffed with cheese, battered, and fried to perfection.
- **Mole Poblano** – Rich, complex sauce over tender chicken, a true taste of Mexico.
**Pro Tip:** Pair your meal with a classic **Margarita** or a refreshing **Horchata** for the full experience.
---
## **2. Jack Dolan’s Irish Pub – A Cozy Taste of Ireland**
? **296 Maple Ave, Smithtown, NY 11787**
? **[Menu](
)**
**Why Visit?**
With its dark wood interiors, live music, and hearty Irish fare, Jack Dolan’s is the perfect spot for a laid-back night out. The pub’s warm atmosphere makes it a great place to unwind with friends.
**Must-Order:**
- **Shepherd’s Pie** – Ground lamb (or beef) topped with creamy mashed potatoes and baked until golden.
- **Fish & Chips** – Crispy beer-battered cod with thick-cut fries and tartar sauce.
- **Irish Breakfast** (Weekend Brunch) – Eggs, bangers, black pudding, baked beans, and toast.
**Pro Tip:** Don’t miss their **Guinness Beef Stew**—slow-cooked to tender perfection.
---
## **3. Maureen’s Kitchen – The Ultimate Breakfast Spot**
? **108 Terry Rd, Smithtown, NY 11787**
? **[Menu](
)**
**Why Visit?**
A beloved breakfast and brunch institution, Maureen’s Kitchen is famous for its fluffy pancakes, creative omelets, and long (but worth-it) weekend lines.
**Must-Order:**
- **Stuffed French Toast** – Thick-cut brioche filled with cream cheese and berries.
- **Irish Benedict** – Corned beef hash topped with poached eggs and hollandaise.
- **Cinnamon Roll Pancakes** – A decadent hybrid of two breakfast favorites.
**Pro Tip:** Arrive early on weekends—this place gets packed!
---
## **4. Timboo – A Hidden Coffee & Café Gem**
? **905 W Jericho Turnpike, Smithtown, NY 11787**
☕ **[Menu](
)**
**Why Visit?**
A cozy spot for coffee lovers and light bites, Timboo offers artisanal brews, smoothies, and sandwiches in a relaxed setting.
**Must-Order:**
- **Avocado Toast** – Thick sourdough with smashed avocado, cherry tomatoes, and feta.
- **Iced Matcha Latte** – Creamy and perfectly balanced.
- **Turkey & Brie Panini** – Warm, melty, and satisfying.
**Pro Tip:** Their **Nutella Latte** is a sweet treat worth indulging in.
---
## **5. Weinisch’s Deli – A Long Island Classic**
? **306 Maple Ave, Smithtown, NY 11787**
? **[Menu](
)**
**Why Visit?**
A no-frills deli with legendary sandwiches piled high with fresh meats and toppings.
**Must-Order:**
- **Pastrami on Rye** – Stacked high with house-smoked pastrami.
- **The Godfather** – Prosciutto, capicola, mozzarella, roasted peppers, and balsamic glaze.
- **Mac Salad** – A creamy, tangy side that’s a Long Island staple.
**Pro Tip:** Grab a **Taylor Ham, Egg & Cheese** for breakfast—it’s a Jersey classic with a loyal following.
---
## **6. Halal Point – Bold Middle Eastern Flavors**
? **1020 W Jericho Turnpike, Smithtown, NY 11787**
? **[Menu](
)**
**Why Visit?**
For authentic halal street food, this spot delivers juicy platters, wraps, and falafel that rival NYC’s best.
**Must-Order:**
- **Chicken Over Rice** – Tender, spiced chicken atop fragrant yellow rice with white sauce.
- **Lamb Gyro** – Crispy-edged lamb strips in warm pita with garlic sauce.
- **Baklava** – Flaky, honey-drenched pastry for dessert.
**Pro Tip:** Ask for extra **hot sauce** if you like a kick!
---
## **7. Osteria Umbra – Upscale Italian Dining**
? **197 Terry Rd, Smithtown, NY 11787**
? **[Menu](
)**
**Why Visit?**
Elegant yet welcoming, Osteria Umbra serves refined Italian dishes with house-made pastas and an impressive wine list.
**Must-Order:**
- **Truffle Tagliatelle** – Fresh pasta with wild mushrooms and truffle cream.
- **Branzino al Forno** – Whole roasted sea bass with lemon and herbs.
- **Tiramisu** – Light, boozy, and the perfect ending.
**Pro Tip:** Reserve ahead—this place is popular for date nights.
---
## **8. H2O Seafood & Sushi – Fresh Coastal Bites**
? **215 W Main St, Smithtown, NY 11787**
? **[Menu](
)**
**Why Visit?**
A sleek spot for sushi lovers and seafood enthusiasts, H2O offers fresh rolls, oysters, and creative cocktails.
**Must-Order:**
- **Dragon Roll** – Eel, avocado, and cucumber topped with spicy mayo.
- **Lobster Roll** – Buttery chunks of lobster on a toasted bun.
- **Tuna Tartare** – Fresh, citrusy, and addictive.
**Pro Tip:** Try their **Sake Sangria** for a fun twist.
---
## **9. Empire Ginger – Pan-Asian Excellence**
? **294 Maple Ave, Smithtown, NY 11787**
? **[Menu](
)**
**Why Visit?**
From sushi to Thai curries, Empire Ginger delivers bold Asian flavors in a stylish setting.
**Must-Order:**
- **Pad Thai** – Perfectly balanced sweet, sour, and nutty flavors.
- **Szechuan Beef** – Spicy, crispy, and packed with heat.
- **Rainbow Roll** – A colorful sushi favorite.
**Pro Tip:** Their **Mango Sticky Rice** is a must for dessert.
---
## **10. Sal’s of Smithtown – Classic Italian-American Comfort**
? **60 Terry Rd, Smithtown, NY 11787**
? **[Menu](
)**
**Why Visit?**
A Long Island staple, Sal’s serves up massive portions of pizza, pasta, and parm dishes in a lively setting.
**Must-Order:**
- **Grandma Pie** – Thin-crust, square-cut, and loaded with fresh basil.
- **Chicken Parmigiana** – Crispy, saucy, and cheesy perfection.
- **Garlic Knots** – Warm, buttery, and impossible to resist.
**Pro Tip:** Order the **Zeppoles** for dessert—fried dough bliss.
---
### **Final Thoughts**
Smithtown’s dining scene is a delightful mix of comfort food, international flavors, and hidden gems. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty Irish meal, a delicate sushi platter, or a classic deli sandwich, this town has it all.
**Which spot will you try first?** ???
Nestled in the heart of Long Island, Smithtown, New York, is a hidden gem for food lovers. From authentic Italian trattorias to cozy Irish pubs and bustling delis, this charming town offers a diverse culinary scene that caters to every palate. Whether you're craving fresh seafood, hearty breakfasts, or bold international flavors, Smithtown has something delicious waiting for you.
Join us as we explore ten of the best dining spots in town, highlighting must-try dishes, ambiance, and what makes each place special.
---
## **1. Casa Luis – A Taste of Mexico on Jericho Turnpike**
? **1033 W Jericho Turnpike, Smithtown, NY 11787**
? **[Menu](
)**
**Why Visit?**
Casa Luis brings the vibrant flavors of Mexico to Smithtown with its colorful decor, friendly service, and bold dishes. The restaurant is a local favorite for its generous portions and authentic recipes.
**Must-Order:**
- **Carne Asada Tacos** – Tender grilled steak, fresh cilantro, and onions on warm corn tortillas.
- **Chiles Rellenos** – Poblano peppers stuffed with cheese, battered, and fried to perfection.
- **Mole Poblano** – Rich, complex sauce over tender chicken, a true taste of Mexico.
**Pro Tip:** Pair your meal with a classic **Margarita** or a refreshing **Horchata** for the full experience.
---
## **2. Jack Dolan’s Irish Pub – A Cozy Taste of Ireland**
? **296 Maple Ave, Smithtown, NY 11787**
? **[Menu](
)**
**Why Visit?**
With its dark wood interiors, live music, and hearty Irish fare, Jack Dolan’s is the perfect spot for a laid-back night out. The pub’s warm atmosphere makes it a great place to unwind with friends.
**Must-Order:**
- **Shepherd’s Pie** – Ground lamb (or beef) topped with creamy mashed potatoes and baked until golden.
- **Fish & Chips** – Crispy beer-battered cod with thick-cut fries and tartar sauce.
- **Irish Breakfast** (Weekend Brunch) – Eggs, bangers, black pudding, baked beans, and toast.
**Pro Tip:** Don’t miss their **Guinness Beef Stew**—slow-cooked to tender perfection.
---
## **3. Maureen’s Kitchen – The Ultimate Breakfast Spot**
? **108 Terry Rd, Smithtown, NY 11787**
? **[Menu](
)**
**Why Visit?**
A beloved breakfast and brunch institution, Maureen’s Kitchen is famous for its fluffy pancakes, creative omelets, and long (but worth-it) weekend lines.
**Must-Order:**
- **Stuffed French Toast** – Thick-cut brioche filled with cream cheese and berries.
- **Irish Benedict** – Corned beef hash topped with poached eggs and hollandaise.
- **Cinnamon Roll Pancakes** – A decadent hybrid of two breakfast favorites.
**Pro Tip:** Arrive early on weekends—this place gets packed!
---
## **4. Timboo – A Hidden Coffee & Café Gem**
? **905 W Jericho Turnpike, Smithtown, NY 11787**
☕ **[Menu](
)**
**Why Visit?**
A cozy spot for coffee lovers and light bites, Timboo offers artisanal brews, smoothies, and sandwiches in a relaxed setting.
**Must-Order:**
- **Avocado Toast** – Thick sourdough with smashed avocado, cherry tomatoes, and feta.
- **Iced Matcha Latte** – Creamy and perfectly balanced.
- **Turkey & Brie Panini** – Warm, melty, and satisfying.
**Pro Tip:** Their **Nutella Latte** is a sweet treat worth indulging in.
---
## **5. Weinisch’s Deli – A Long Island Classic**
? **306 Maple Ave, Smithtown, NY 11787**
? **[Menu](
)**
**Why Visit?**
A no-frills deli with legendary sandwiches piled high with fresh meats and toppings.
**Must-Order:**
- **Pastrami on Rye** – Stacked high with house-smoked pastrami.
- **The Godfather** – Prosciutto, capicola, mozzarella, roasted peppers, and balsamic glaze.
- **Mac Salad** – A creamy, tangy side that’s a Long Island staple.
**Pro Tip:** Grab a **Taylor Ham, Egg & Cheese** for breakfast—it’s a Jersey classic with a loyal following.
---
## **6. Halal Point – Bold Middle Eastern Flavors**
? **1020 W Jericho Turnpike, Smithtown, NY 11787**
? **[Menu](
)**
**Why Visit?**
For authentic halal street food, this spot delivers juicy platters, wraps, and falafel that rival NYC’s best.
**Must-Order:**
- **Chicken Over Rice** – Tender, spiced chicken atop fragrant yellow rice with white sauce.
- **Lamb Gyro** – Crispy-edged lamb strips in warm pita with garlic sauce.
- **Baklava** – Flaky, honey-drenched pastry for dessert.
**Pro Tip:** Ask for extra **hot sauce** if you like a kick!
---
## **7. Osteria Umbra – Upscale Italian Dining**
? **197 Terry Rd, Smithtown, NY 11787**
? **[Menu](
)**
**Why Visit?**
Elegant yet welcoming, Osteria Umbra serves refined Italian dishes with house-made pastas and an impressive wine list.
**Must-Order:**
- **Truffle Tagliatelle** – Fresh pasta with wild mushrooms and truffle cream.
- **Branzino al Forno** – Whole roasted sea bass with lemon and herbs.
- **Tiramisu** – Light, boozy, and the perfect ending.
**Pro Tip:** Reserve ahead—this place is popular for date nights.
---
## **8. H2O Seafood & Sushi – Fresh Coastal Bites**
? **215 W Main St, Smithtown, NY 11787**
? **[Menu](
)**
**Why Visit?**
A sleek spot for sushi lovers and seafood enthusiasts, H2O offers fresh rolls, oysters, and creative cocktails.
**Must-Order:**
- **Dragon Roll** – Eel, avocado, and cucumber topped with spicy mayo.
- **Lobster Roll** – Buttery chunks of lobster on a toasted bun.
- **Tuna Tartare** – Fresh, citrusy, and addictive.
**Pro Tip:** Try their **Sake Sangria** for a fun twist.
---
## **9. Empire Ginger – Pan-Asian Excellence**
? **294 Maple Ave, Smithtown, NY 11787**
? **[Menu](
)**
**Why Visit?**
From sushi to Thai curries, Empire Ginger delivers bold Asian flavors in a stylish setting.
**Must-Order:**
- **Pad Thai** – Perfectly balanced sweet, sour, and nutty flavors.
- **Szechuan Beef** – Spicy, crispy, and packed with heat.
- **Rainbow Roll** – A colorful sushi favorite.
**Pro Tip:** Their **Mango Sticky Rice** is a must for dessert.
---
## **10. Sal’s of Smithtown – Classic Italian-American Comfort**
? **60 Terry Rd, Smithtown, NY 11787**
? **[Menu](
)**
**Why Visit?**
A Long Island staple, Sal’s serves up massive portions of pizza, pasta, and parm dishes in a lively setting.
**Must-Order:**
- **Grandma Pie** – Thin-crust, square-cut, and loaded with fresh basil.
- **Chicken Parmigiana** – Crispy, saucy, and cheesy perfection.
- **Garlic Knots** – Warm, buttery, and impossible to resist.
**Pro Tip:** Order the **Zeppoles** for dessert—fried dough bliss.
---
### **Final Thoughts**
Smithtown’s dining scene is a delightful mix of comfort food, international flavors, and hidden gems. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty Irish meal, a delicate sushi platter, or a classic deli sandwich, this town has it all.
**Which spot will you try first?** ???
Comments
Post a Comment